Judge Allison D. Burroughs:
ELECTRONIC ORDER entered. On October 24, 2022, the Court held a status conference that was attended by all parties to this action. [ECF No. 44 ]. During the hearing, Plaintiff requested, and was granted, leave to electronically file as a pro se litigant. [ECF No. 45 ]. He subsequently made use of the Court’s electronic filing system and filed on October 31, 2022 a motion for clarification and a motion to transfer. [ECF Nos. 49 – 50 ]. On November 7, 2022, Defendants Abrams and Peter each answered Plaintiff’s complaint and filed counterclaims. [ECF Nos. 53 – 54 ].
The following day, November 8, 2022, Plaintiff sent an email to the clerk of the court in which he claimed that he had attempted to file a notice of voluntary dismissal (the “Notice”) on November 6, 2022 at 12:17 p.m.—i.e., before Defendants answered—and attached to his email a screenshot of his browsing history on Google Chrome, which he described as “metadata,” as well as a PDF of the Notice, which was dated November 5, 2022. Thereafter, on November 9, 2022, Plaintiff electronically filed on the docket a letter that reiterated his claim that he filed his Notice on November 6, 2022 and asked the Court to investigate the purported “missing file” and to “correct the error in its record.” [ECF No. 55 ]. The clerk of the court then, on November 10, 2022, entered on the docket the Notice that Plaintiff attached to his November 8, 2022 email. See [ECF No. 56 ].
Other than the date on the Notice, which was sent to the clerk on November 8, 2022 and later entered on November 10, 2022, see [ECF No. 56 ], there is no evidence to suggest that Plaintiff drafted the Notice or attempted to file it prior to Defendants answering his complaint and filing counterclaims. As discussed, Plaintiff was granted leave to file electronically on October 24, 2022 and successfully did so on October 31, 2022—a week before he allegedly encountered issues with electronic filing. The Court further notes that any technological issues Plaintiff encountered on November 6, 2022 appear to have resolved as he was able to electronically file a letter on the docket on November 9, 2022. Plaintiff has also not offered any explanation as to why, if he was unable to file the Notice on November 6, 2022, he did not attempt to refile the notice and did not alert the Court of his inability to file until two days later and, importantly, after Defendants had answered and counterclaimed.
In any event, because Defendants answered his complaint and counterclaimed, pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 41 the Court may only dismiss the action with Defendants agreement. Defendants are therefore ORDERED to indicate, in a written filing, whether they consent to dismissal of this action by November 18, 2022.
(McManus, Caetlin) (Entered: 11/10/2022)